2026年9月24日 第4频道播出49分 调度 调查打开怀特霍尔的档案柜 而不是废墟上的另一卷 英国的广场秘密曝光由Ramita Navai介绍,由Ben De Pear制作,阅读了外交部部长用来向以色列发放武器许可证的评估,而以色列部队则平息了 加沙。前第四频道新闻编辑德·皮尔告诉 现在民主! what the pages showed. “We were looking at how our country, which prides itself on having an ethical foreign policy and as being one of the supporting members of the United Nations on human rights, was able to keep selling arms,” he said. “And basically, what we found was a doctored process. It’s quite extraordinary the level of duplicity that was going on in order for us to keep selling Israel arms.”
That process ran under a genocide conducted in the open. Gaza’s Health Ministry, whose counts U.N. agencies treat as broadly reliable, reported 74,016 Palestinians killed and about 175,068 wounded by September 27, 2026, roughly half of them women and children. A ceasefire on October 10, 2025, did not stop the killing. The ministry says more than a thousand Palestinians have died since, while Israeli forces still hold over half of Gaza. AEGIS联盟报告了对这些侵犯行为的区域谴责.
用于返回“ 不够” 的方法
Much of the material surfaced in a case brought by Al-Haq and the Global Legal Action Network to stop the exports. Officials reviewed hundreds of videos of attacks on civilians, schools, hospitals, and aid workers. In most incidents they found too little information to identify a breach of humanitarian law, because Israel had not handed over “sufficient evidence” about the target.
William Schabas, who read the assessments for the program, named the design. “My impression from looking at all this material is that the British government has adopted what looks like a methodology, but one designed to produce a result that no violations are taking place.” If the army under review can withhold the only facts the reviewer will accept, the finding is decided before the video is watched.
纳瓦伊告诉 新阿拉伯党 the failure ran through both the Conservative and Labour governments. “The apparent bias towards Israel means our government may have breached international law,” she said. “Our institutions should never be bent for any ally, and there needs to be accountability, especially when it is about genocide.”
案卷不会决定的
The famous cases were not skipped. They were filed and left open. Five-year-old Hind Rajab was trapped in a car in Gaza City among dead relatives, pleading by phone for rescue, and was later found killed. The assessment recorded no breach, citing a lack of Israeli information. The army first denied it had been there. In August 2026, the film reports, it admitted its soldiers fired on the car. A strike on Al-Fakhoura school in Jabalia reportedly killed at least 24 people and produced no finding, because Israel never described a military objective. In Al-Mawasi, inside a zone Israel had labeled humanitarian, a strike hit four British doctors whose compound had been coordinated with the military. Conflicting Israeli accounts still yielded no decision that the attack was even a possible breach.
The April 1, 2024, strike on a World Central Kitchen convoy is harder to call a mystery, because Israel admitted it. Seven aid workers were killed, three of them British veterans. Israel called the attack a “grave mistake” and dismissed two officers. Two days later, while David Cameron was still demanding answers in public, his office agreed not to suspend the licences already issued. The same contempt shows up in 以色列向美国支持的一个粮食点开枪 内 摧毁巴勒斯坦人的平生.
卡梅伦已经读过的东西
In January 2024, with more than 23,000 Palestinians dead and water cut across a three-month blockade, Cameron faced the Foreign Affairs Committee. Asked if lawyers had warned him of breaches, he said he was not a lawyer and could not recall every paper. The film counts ten evasions. About a month earlier he had received two assessments finding that Israel’s restrictions on relief were a possible breach of humanitarian law. An email says he “carefully considered all the information” in one of them. He still ruled that Israel was committed to the law overall, and the exports went on.
A later note is more damaging. Cameron concluded that from December 2023 to January 2024 Israel had not been committed to humanitarian law on relief, then decided that did not justify suspending licences. He wrote that a suspension would have a “significant impact on UK interests,” letting convenience outrank the real test: a clear risk the goods might be used to commit or facilitate a serious violation.
一个外交官说系统坏了
Mark Smith had led British arms assessments during the Saudi-led war in Yemen, and he resigned from the Foreign Office in August 2024 because ministers would not stop sales to Israel. An actor speaks his words in the film. “The nature of the assessment is such that you can kind of make it say whatever you want, and that is why the system is broken.” Then the line the criteria were built to avoid: “If there is even a question, whether domestically or internationally, that a state that you are selling arms to might be conducting a genocide, then the time to be discussing whether they might be in breach of IHL is way gone.”
Officials told the program the clash between civil servants and ministers over Gaza was sharper than in any war they had staffed. Hundreds warned of British complicity and were ordered not to write “ethnic cleansing” or “genocide.” A June 2024 assessment still called it “uncontentious” that acts meeting the physical element of genocide were underway, while saying intent was unproved. London’s line, under both parties, is that only a court may use the word. The Genocide Convention does not wait for a final judgment.
使战机幸免的中止
After Labour took office, David Lammy on September 2, 2024, suspended about 29 licences where there was a clear risk British equipment could facilitate serious violations in Gaza. Six more were later suspended or changed. The break with the Conservatives was narrower than the headline. F-35 components were carved out.
Britain makes about 15 percent of each F-35. Israel flies roughly 45 and has used them over Gaza, including a strike on a supposed safe zone in Al-Mawasi that killed about 90 people on the day Lammy spoke. Direct shipments of those parts to Israel stopped. Parts feeding the global spares pool, which can still reach the jets, did not. Ministers set the normal licensing rules aside, including duties linked to humanitarian law and the Genocide Convention, and said a wider cutoff would hurt “international peace and security” and annoy Washington.
法律援助会没有获得充分听证。 2025年6月30日,高等法院拒绝允许司法审查,并搁置核心条约问题. 截止2026年2月28日的数字从2025年8月1日起签发的112份涉及以色列的许可证。 反对武器贸易运动 称F -35豁免 英国最大的物质部分 在攻击。 这种模式贯穿加沙。 在加沙灭绝种族行为之外,黎巴嫩的行动已经展开,以及 以色列部队已经与严重侵犯事件相挂钩 伙伴们很迟缓地认为是阻止武器的原因。
The Foreign Office calls those assessments “among the most robust and rigorous in the world.” Israel says it fights from necessity, inside the law, and tries to spare civilians. A department that bans the word genocide, then treats Israeli silence as a reason nothing can be decided, is not running a test. It is building a paper wall around a crime.
语句不能编辑文件
On September 28, 2026, at Labour’s conference in Liverpool, Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband called Netanyahu’s conduct in Gaza “a stain on the conscience of the world” and said evidence of war crimes was mounting. He condemned the Hamas-led attacks of October 7, 2023, which killed about 1,200 people in Israel and saw 251 taken hostage, and said those crimes do not excuse what has been done to Palestinians. He named ethnic cleansing by “settler terrorists” in the occupied West Bank and promised sanctions on settlement goods, telling campaigners they had been right that Labour’s earlier line was too weak.
De Pear called the shift real and late. A conference line does not pull a part from a fighter jet, or give Hind Rajab back the call she made from the car. Britain signed the Arms Trade Treaty and the Genocide Convention. Both required a halt when the risk was already plain, not a partial freeze that left the main aircraft supplied, and not a ban on vocabulary in the office that scores the risk.
阿拉伯-英国谅解理事会的克里斯·道尔(Chris Doyle)告诉《新阿拉伯报》,部长们无视他们在叙利亚或乌克兰不会吞并的侵权行为。 推进器仍然必须回答。 命令将人道主义团体赶出加沙 把现场的证人带走 这部电影是怀特霍尔的见证. 伦敦看到足够多,写足够多,并安排了结论,使许可证能够活下来. 更多记录在 联盟的国际办公室 和在 政治文件种族灭绝并不需要每个盟友投下炸弹。 它需要足够 保持文件清洁。
